Non Canon One Piece RolePlay

NEWS
Hello and welcome to Strawhats! We hope you have fun and enjoy the site.
If you have any questions jump in our chatbox and ask away.
You can also join our site Discord chat here! *https://discord.gg/JhBS8Yy.*
Our current ongoing events is:
*Birth by Storm* * = links

Log in

I forgot my password



STAFF LIST
OWNER
https://i.servimg.com/u/f62/19/21/38/42/admin_13.png
ADMINISTRATORS
https://i.servimg.com/u/f62/19/21/38/42/kaito_11.png https://i.servimg.com/u/f62/19/21/38/42/devrou10.png https://i.imgur.com/1vaJQJc.png https://i.imgur.com/HBb1nBA.png
MODERATORS
https://i.servimg.com/u/f62/19/21/38/42/melly_11.png https://i.imgur.com/q5z5reU.png
DEVELOPERS
https://i.servimg.com/u/f62/19/21/38/42/noctis10.png
EVALUATOR
https://i.servimg.com/u/f42/18/53/44/60/sofiai10.png https://i.imgur.com/x2u1mnO.png
BATTLE MOD
https://i.servimg.com/u/f62/19/21/38/42/hannib10.png https://i.servimg.com/u/f95/18/53/44/60/temps_10.png
Latest topics
» Missions, Milestones, & Refferals
Today at 8:07 am by Kincaid

» Perusing The Merchandise [CV]
Today at 8:06 am by Kincaid

» [GV] Helios Bandits In - Voluptatem Debutante Pila
Today at 2:39 am by Kaito

» ZapdosZulu: Pokemon RPG
Today at 12:26 am by Guest

» Tryouts [Solo Voyage]
Yesterday at 10:07 pm by Strategos

» Notification Topic
Yesterday at 8:31 pm by MoonlightButterfly

» Lumos in the Dark (premium jcink)
Yesterday at 7:30 pm by Guest

» The Chaos at the Common Ground (Gran Voyage)
Yesterday at 6:24 pm by Winged Menace

» A call to service{Baltigo to Lulusia Kingdom}
Yesterday at 12:16 pm by Winged Menace

Statistics
We have 339 registered users
The newest registered user is Suzu

Our users have posted a total of 23951 messages in 3460 subjects

You are not connected. Please login or register

View previous topic View next topic Go down  Message [Page 1 of 1]

1 Dispute The First Customer [Social/Crafting] on Mon Nov 26, 2018 3:29 pm

Daimaru

Pirate
Pirate

avatar
I would like to have Sabo kicked from my thread. He was not invited and he invaded the thread. He has No IC reasoning to be there. Not to mention he's been invading nonstop other threads and I was told you can't invade all thread. Yes, threads are technically open however How does he even know me and Kincaid are on the island so I think he used metagaming knowledge because Kincaid and I have talked about getting together to fix my arm so I would like him removed, please.

http://strawhats.forumotion.com/t3030-the-first-customer-social-crafting

Poopy Face

Revolutionary
Revolutionary

avatar
@Daimaru wrote:I would like to have  Sabo kicked from my thread. He was not invited and he invaded the thread. He has No IC reasoning to be there. Not to mention he's been invading nonstop other threads and I was told you can't invade all thread. Yes, threads are technically open however How does he even know me and Kincaid are on the island so I think he used metagaming knowledge because Kincaid and I have talked about getting together to fix my arm so I would like him removed, please.

http://strawhats.forumotion.com/t3030-the-first-customer-social-crafting

I do not appreciate these allegations. I do not need to be invited to this thread to join in. I have not been "invading nonstop" that is a complete lie you are trying to use to create a false narrative on this situation. I don't need to know anyone is only the Island....just a stroke of luck I ended up in the same bar as you. Just how it was a stroke of luck you found a scientist that could give you a arm right after you arrived back to the Island.

Noctis

Vagabond
Vagabond

avatar
@Daimaru wrote:I would like to have  Sabo kicked from my thread. He was not invited and he invaded the thread. He has No IC reasoning to be there. Not to mention he's been invading nonstop other threads and I was told you can't invade all thread. Yes, threads are technically open however How does he even know me and Kincaid are on the island so I think he used metagaming knowledge because Kincaid and I have talked about getting together to fix my arm so I would like him removed, please.

http://strawhats.forumotion.com/t3030-the-first-customer-social-crafting
I'm gonna go ahead and rule on this myself since it doesn't really require further escalation in any way.

Yeah, no. That's not really how this works. Metagaming knowledge is only really a "voidable" offence if someone abuses it to grant themselves an advantage in someway. For example, someone showing up at a place you were set to meet at hours before you get there and setting traps or prepping in some way shape or form.

Him coincidentally showing up in a open social/crafting topic doesn't even come close to those parameters.

Was your meetup location secret and/or hidden from outsiders somehow? I don't believe so. Either way, his presence is fine and you should consider this an opportunity for character growth. Things won't always go as anticipated.

Lady Sofia

Vagabond
Vagabond

avatar
This isn't a ruling but a comment. You can lock social threads, but you have to state all of the possible participants in the first post, which you haven't. The first post would have had to indicate all potential participants (as well as that it's actually "Locked", likely).

In the future, please consider this option.

http://strawhats.forumotion.com/t5-voyage wrote:What also sets Normal/Social topics apart from others is that they can be locked. The first post indicating all potential participants. Locked topics are exempt from claiming rewards. Topics will be unlocked if a NPC has to come in or if actions deem it not a isolated encounter. A isolated encounter being a crew talking on their ship or other areas that belong to one of them, such as turf.

Poopy Face

Revolutionary
Revolutionary

avatar
The topic couldn’t be locked regardless from how it was set up. It takes place in a bar goofy so move around. Could’ve DM’d him that information.

Lady Sofia

Vagabond
Vagabond

avatar
@Poopy Face wrote:The topic couldn’t be locked regardless from how it was set up. It takes place in a bar goofy so move around. Could’ve DM’d him that information.

Lmao, how it could have been locked with the right set-up is right there in the quote, don't say it couldn't have been. Plus, it's information that can be useful for anyone else in this situation, not only them.

Poopy Face

Revolutionary
Revolutionary

avatar
Topics will be unlocked if a NPC has to come in or if actions deem it not a isolated encounter. A isolated encounter being a crew talking on their ship or other areas that belong to one of them, such as turf.


This is not a I S O L A T E D encounter. Nor could it have been. Neither of the other participants have turf on this Island nor a ship. But if they had set it up differently me joining or anyone else for that matter would’ve been impossible. I don’t exspect someone that doesn’t know SHIT about combat rp to understand how to set up a topic so people can’t join. You are unneeded and I’ll-equipped to speak on this topic or similar situations like this at all. You commented just to comment. So like I said before...move around goofy.

Devroux

Admin

avatar
Both @Lady Sofia and @Noctis have different points to make, but the end idea is the same - @Poopy Face is breaking no rules. He's already built at least a base-level relationship with the other participants IC before, so he's good to go.

Carry on.

Sponsored content



View previous topic View next topic Back to top  Message [Page 1 of 1]

Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum